What should I get?

So since I'm ordering a controller from amazon, I also wanna get a game.

I'm looking for a good one player campaign. Basically I have it down to two: Devil May Cry 4 and Resident Evil 5.

I'll get RE5 if I can get someone to go through the game with. I don't think I can convince Sarah to play with me. Plus my constant yelling of "HEAL ME! NOW!" might put a strain on our relationship.

DMC4 looks good but I've never played any of the DMC games. It looks like a God of War type game (which I enjoyed for the PS2).

Any thoughts/other recommendations?